Industry, Innovation and Infrastructure
Nature and selectiveness of social policy
It was in the 1980s that proposals for the targeting or focusing of social expenditure on the poor gained ground. These proposals contrast universality and selectivity in terms of a dilemma in a disjunctive relationship; targeting or universal policies, or targeting versus universal policies.
The Latin American Labour Market, 1950-1990
This article contrasts the behaviour of the labour market in the region between 1950 and 1980 with that registered after the onset of the crisis of the 1980s,
The history of the social stratification of Latin America
Sociology’s contribution to our understanding of the Latin American development process has been closely linked to studies on the social structure and stratification of the region and to analyses and interpretations of the various social groups’ characters and behaviour.
Latin America’s return to the private international capital market
A necessary condilion in order for Latin America to attain acceptable economic growth is the reduction of the negative resource transfer abroad. In addition to the reduction of the existing external debt burden, a substantial volume of fresh external financing is needed, but commercial bank loans will continue to be limited and official lenders can hardly satisfy all the region’s needs.
Commodity exports and Latin American development
In the past, international cooperation in the area of commodities has been concentrated on measures to stabilize world prices through agreements between producers and consumers. At present, the questions of the level and stability of world prices continue to be just as important as ever, but there are few possibilities of resuming international cooperation of this type. Furthermore, the level of final prices is only one of the problems related with production costs (which in turn depend on the technologies applied) and other aspects regarding the added value retained in the producer countries.
The Pacific Basin and Latin America
This article analyses three aspects of the economic relations between South-east Asia and Latin America: i) the true extent of the headway made by four newly industrializing Asian economies (NIEs) (the Republic of Korea, Hong Kong, Taiwan and Singapore) and four ASEAN countries (Indonesia, the Philippines, Malaysia and Thailand) in the new Asian economic order; ii) their economic relations -particularly those of the Republic of Korea and Taiwan- with Latin America; and iii) the implications of the Pacific Basin’s new economic profilé in terms of the effort to change production patterns with social equity in Latin America.
Flying geese or sitting ducks? Transnationals and industry in developing countries
The constitution of a new international industrial order dominated by a core of large transnational corporations generally makes life more difficult for the great majority of developing countries because, since most are not in a position to compete effectively, they face still greater marginalization.
Reorientation of Central American integration
The Central American countries promoted a vigorous integration process which gave rise to valuable experience. The increased trade furthered industrialization and stimulated investment, modernization of production and economic growth. However, the exhaustion of the past growth model based on agricultural exports and the persistence of the system of over-protection of substitution industry, which was continued longer than was necessary, led to a profound crisis in the economies and in the integration programme itself.
Income distribution and poverty through crisis and adjustment
This article analyses the costs in terms of income distribution of the crisis and adjustments of the 1980s, as well as the effects of the subsequent recovery and resumption of sustained growth patterns. This analysis is based on comparable pairs of estimates of income distribution and poverty prepared by ECLAC for the ten largest and predominantly urban countries of the region.
Social investment funds in Latin America
This article deals with various aspects relating to social investment funds, especially their financing, the sustainability of the resulting projects, and the role of funds vis-à-vis ministries and the political authorities. The links between such funds and non-governmental organizations and the role played by external cooperation are also examined. Social investment funds were set up in order to relieve poverty and soften the effects of the adjustment policies of the 1980s. They have proved to be effective means of channeling flows of external finance and ensuring that they result in concrete projects. The main strategy used for transferring resources to the poor has been the creation of temporary jobs in connection with the execution of projects in the areas of social and economic infrastructure, as well as projects designed to satisfy basic needs.
New directions for public management
Consideration of the roles to be played by the public and private sectors in a country’s developm ent strategy naturally leads to an analysis of the public sector’s main orientations regarding both its own actions and the establishm ent of a regulatory framework for the performance of certain types of activities. These orientations are expressed through public policies, i.e., the courses of action followed by the public sector in pursuance of a more or less well-defined objective.
The petrochemical and machine tool industries: Business strategies
Recent structural reforms in Argentina, Brazil and Mexico have set up entirely new conditions for competition. The biggest changes are those affecting trade and industrial policy and the system of public-private production relations. In this new environment, manufacturing firms receive less protection and less State assistance and have less leeway in which to devise price differentiation strategies for the domestic market.
Agroindustry and changing production patterns in small-scale agriculture
The extension of technological progress to sm all-scale agricultural producers is an unavoidable issue in any strategy aimed at changing production patterns with equity in the rural environment. With a few exceptions, analysis of the achievements of public policies in this area reveals that they have fallen far short of their goals even in periods when the restrictions on public spending were nothing like as severe as those faced by the economies of the region today.
Labour market flexibility: What does it really mean?
The 1980s witnessed the emergence of the concept “labour market flexibility” (LMF) in industrialized countries as well as in some developing countries. As a consequence of poor economic performance in the early 1980s, the view that the way in which labour markets operated constituted a significant obstacle to economic growth gained support at the level of policy makers, employers in general and, not least, in part of the academic establishment.
The impact of exchange-rate and trade policy on export performance in the 1980s
The region’s changeover from a shortage of external funds to a relatively plentiful supply of such resources at a time when an effort is being made to liberalize its trade and financial sectors raises a number of questions regarding the effect of this phenomenon on the growth of Latin American exports. In an effort to answer these questions, the author examines a number of different attempts to arrive at a quantitative evaluation of the relationship between exchange and trade policies and the region’s export performance in the 1980s.
Fiscal adjustment and social spending
The external and internal imbalances that appeared in the early 1980s, together with the adjustment and stabilization policies applied throughout that decade in Latin America, juxtaposed the need to reduce the fiscal deficit with the need to make up for the loss of income sustained by the most, vulnerable groups of the population as a consequence of the external debt crisis. This article examines patterns of social expenditure in a number of countries in the region, in an effort to determine how these policies affected the level and composition of social spending and, hence, influenced social policy.
The political economy of protection after the Uruguay round
This paper discusses the interplay between domestic policies and foreign interests under the institutional framework to be administered by’ the World Trade Organization (WTO). It presents a theoretical model that treats the WTO as the forum for an overlapping game which provides the rules for the maintenance of an open trading system among economies that are periodically submitted to protectionist pressures. Overlapping games occur when a particular player is engaged at the same time in games against distinct opponents, and when the strategy pursued in one game limits strategies available in the other.
Water management and river basins in Latin America
The sustainability of development remains an academic concept unless it is linked to clear objectives that must be attained in given territories and to the management processes needed to achieve this. Management of the natural resources located within the area of a river basin is a valuable option for guiding and coordinating processes of management for development in the light of environmental variables. In order to turn environmental policies into concrete actions it is necessary to have suitable management bodies, which are normally very complex.
Indicators of fiscal policy: Design and applications for Chile
Latin America’s economics are prone to continual shocks, of both external and internal origin, giving rise to a marked variability in their growth rates. In order to reduce this volatility, it is necessary therefore to establish stabilization mechanisms, including in particular the instruments of fiscal policy. The economies’ increasing variability is prompting the development of fiscal norms that in-corporate anti-cyclical features. Such rules arc based on the setting of medium-term public spending goals that are consistent with the economy’s growth trend and level of public debt but are independent of the cyclical component of the level of activity. In such a system, tax revenues would perform the traditional function of stabilizers of economic fluctuations.
Some lessons of the Argentine privatization process
The reduction of the role of the State in the Latin American economies has become one of the central topics in the debate on the process of the economic and social restructuring of the region. Because of the magnitude and rapidity of its achievements, the programme carried out in Argentina in the early 1990s is seen as a paradigm which gives rise to reflection and offers a broad range of lessons for those countries seeking to maximize the social benefits that could be obtained from the privatization of public enterprises. From this point of view, the present article highlights some of the main macroeconomic repercussions of the privatization process (in the fiscal sphere, the external sector, the structure of relative prices, and investment), together with its effects on market formation and the strategies of the main business conglomerates of the country, the forms of public regulation of the privatized areas, and the limitations and shortcomings observed.
Extraordinary comparative advantage and long-run growth: The case of Ecuador
The objective of this article is to describe how the transformation of the trade and industrialization regime is taking place in Ecuador and what are the systemic factors which condition the realization of this transformation. A long-run perspective of economic policy and growth in Ecuador (considering the whole of the twentieth century) reveals that growth has been relatively fast compared to other countries in the region, with exports as the driving force of that growth. The disturbing fact is that these exports have been dominated by a few booming export products at different points in time, and that growth has therefore shown a distinct stop-go nature. Corporate behaviour would seem to be characterized by rent-seeking, as natural economic rents have been present at several moments in history.
Port privatization, labour reform and social equity
Governments of the ECLAC region have promulgated labour regimes which support port workers’ desire for stable wages and job security, isolate them from market signals and create cargo-handling monopolies. The advent of a global economy, the introduction of export-led growth policies, the acquisition of advanced cargo-handling equipment and electronic information systems, and the participation of private interests in the offer of port services permit enterprises to compare, purchase and employ raw materials, labour and service inputs worldwide, and have transformed the traditional concept of competition between comparable finished goods into input-to-final product competition.
Democracy and development
First of all, I should like to say how grateful I am for the kindness with which I have been received everywhere I have been in Chile. Nevertheless, ECLAC has a very special meaning for me. I am perhaps a little conservative in my habits, although not so much in my way of thinking, as Enzo Faletto seems to think …
Can growth and equity go hand in hand?
This article presents the issue in the context of the theoretical and empirical debate, started by Kuznets, on the possibility of achieving growth with equity. The conclusion is that there is no inevitable conflict between these two goals, provided that economic policy promotes the areas of complementarity between growth and equity. It therefore rejects the approaches which assume that there is an insoluble conflict between these objectives, such as the “trickle-down” theory (which stoically accepts that such a conflict exists and proposes that those affected should wait as long as is necessary for their situation to improve) and the contrasting “parallel” approach (which suggests that growth should be sacrificed in favour of equity, with social policy being entrusted with the correction of the worst distributive effects of economic policy).
Virtues and limitations of census maps for identifying critical deficiencies
Critical deficiency maps, conceived as objective, uniformly applicable technical tools that could be employed to make social expenditure more efficient and effective, constitute the most ambitious and successful method devised to date for using census data for social planning in Latin America and the Caribbean. Nevertheless, while their importance and potential as a policy tool have gained increasing recognition, questions have arisen concerning their virtues and limitations and on how they could be made to serve the need for more complex social information or to reveal the changing forms that poverty assumes.
The United Nations and ECLAC at the half-century mark of the Organization
Fifty years ago, a broad and representative group of countries tried for the second time in this century to set up a world organization to try to banish the scourge of war and promote international co-operation. The first attempt -the League of Nations- had foundered in the stormy waters that were to lead to the greatest cataclysm in world history. The second effort -the United Nations- has so far resisted different but equally severe trials, notably the so-called “Cold War”.
Economic relations between Latin America and the high-performing Asian developing economies
This study examines “South-South” economic relations in the context of regionalism. It covers three Latin American countries and eight high-performing Asian developing economics. Although the level of trade and investment between these two groups is currently very low, trade is growing fast and there are indications that the potential for continued growth exists. Although regionalism is advancing in both these parts of the world, it has so far not affected the ties between the two groups of countries, and in fact inter-regional trade growth has recently been exceeding intra-regional growth in the case of most of the countries covered by this study. In the short term, it would appear that economic relations between these Latin American and Asian countries will depend largely on whether a “second generation” of reforms in Latin America will sustain the gains from prior reforms.
Transnationalization and integration of production in Latin America
Trade among the ALAD countries has grown with exceptional vigour so far in the 1990s, especially in the branches of metal products, machinery and equipment, chemical products, and foodstuffs, beverages and tobacco. In order for this dynamic growth to be sustainable in the long term, these countries must develop their intra-industry trade by promoting reciprocal supply in those branches. The bulk of transnational productive capital in Latin America is concentrated in those branches, and it is in the metal products, machinery and equipment sector that the swiftest increase in intra-industry trade takes place and the link between the growth of intra-regional trade and a strong presence of transnational capital is most marked.
The ambivalence of Latin American agriculture
What has happened in rural development in recent years means that one must be very chary of the traditional view that agriculture lacks dynamism and is incapable of responding effectively to economic stimuli. On the contrary, output has grown steadily, export agriculture has expanded, the level of technology used has risen and the organization of production has been changing, and all this is closely linked to substantial changes in the make-up and outlook of the agents of production, and notably to the presence of a new rural entrepreneurial class.
Nominal anchors and macroeconomic coordination options In MERCOSUR
This study deals with the question of macroeconomic coordinanation in the context of MERCOSUR, analysing the contribution that different types of nominal anchors (monetary and exchangerate) could make to the achievement of convergence of nominal indicators and sustained economic growth. The possible gains in terms of well-being associated with policy coordination are explored, in order to permit a rational evaluation of proposals for greater monetary coordination. An analysis is made of the problem of selecting the nominal anchor most suitable for serving as the basis for cooperative agreements, in an economy affected by real and monetary disturbances.
Water rights markets: Institutional elements
Water is a scarce resource which has an economic value and fulfills important ecological and social functions. For this reason, it is normally considered a public good of the State, which grants user rights to private individuals. These rights arc usually protected by constitutional provisions regarding private property, since it is assumed that the private sector will not make investments unless it has guaranteed ownership rights. On the other hand, the water in respect of which user rights arc granted must indeed be used for socially beneficial purposes: otherwise the rights arc revoked. There are some systems where the user rights are unconditional, but this is not usual. The legal elements affecting the stability of water rights are of a structural nature: they include rules ensuring stability, those concerning the transfer of such rights, and rules on the recognition of prior uses and rights.
Possible effects of European Union widening on Latin America
Pending widening of the European Union to the East has revived concerns in Latin America that Europe may become more inward-looking. However, booming trade and foreign direct investment relations between current European Union members and Central and Eastern European countries are unlikely to harm Latin America.
The State, business and the restoration of the neoclassical paradigm
The author describes the neoclassical restoration, which, from the 1970s onwards, took a radical approach to the search for a theory of development by attempting to fuse the particular characteristics of developing economies with the central ideas of economic theory. Intervention with the aim of furthering development was perceived not as a solution but as part of the problem, and adjustment programmes were oriented not so much towards correcting imbalances as towards establishing an economic structure close to neo-classical precepts. Several East Asian economies were chosen as examples of the application of correct policy, since they were seen as being market-driven, but closer analysis revealed that behind their export success lay the firm guiding hand of the State.
Growth, distributive justice and social policy
After more than a decade of economic reform and structural adjustment in the developing countries, there is increased recognition that economic growth and social equity must go hand in hand. This article starts by asking what is meant by “social equity". It notes that reduction of poverty and improvement of income distribution are two perfectly complementary policy objectives, since less inequality can help both to reduce poverty and to speed up economic growth. It reviews the main elements of the modem theory of distributive justice, covering the ethical and economic dimensions of inequality.
Worker participation in company profits or operating results in Latin America
Reinventing development: Utopias devised by committees and seeds of change in the real world
International normative declarations on development combine two types of demands that derive from different views of human societies and their future. One type envisages equality for Third World countries within a reformed world order retaining sources of dynamism not very different from the present. The other type of demand, for another development, envisages equality for hum and beings within a world order governed by radically different social relationships, values and incentives. The mixing of these two types of demands, and the failure to make explicit their different theoretical and evaporative premises, while unavoidable in international forums seeking consensus, weakens the convincingness of the declaration either as packages of demands negotiable between governments or as mobilizing myths seeking to replace the waning myth of economic development.
The tax regime for micro-enterprises in Cuba
The government of Cuba established a tax regime for micro-enterprises as soon as it legalized the sector in 1993. It was designed to function in a difficult context in which a tax-paying culture did not exist, in which widespread noncompliance was feared, and in which some micro-entrepreneurs’ incomes were high. The tax regime included advance monthly lump-sum payments, a 10% maximum amount of total revenues which could be deducted as costs in calculating taxable income, and an escalating tax schedule. This tax regime has a number of weaknesses which make it inequitable, inefficient and ineffective in revenue generation. The analysis of this essay indicates that the actual incidence of the tax is higher than the official tax scale when actual production costs exceed the maximum allowable 10%, even exceeding 100% in some circumstances. The up-front lumpsum tax payments result in marginal tax rates of 100% for initial levels of revenue, followed by a rate of 0% until a level of taxable income is reached where taxes payable according to the tax scale are equal to the initial lump-sum payment. The tax regime discriminates against micro-enterprises which have costs of purchased inputs in excess of 10% of gross revenues. It is regressive in that the tax rates are higher for lower-income micro-enterprises up to a fairly significant level of true net income. The micro-enterprise sector also faces a more onerous tax regime than the foreign and joint venture sector of the economy. From the standpoint of its impact on the efficiency of resource use, the tax regime restricts the entry of new firms into the sector and forces some out of business or underground, thereby reducing production, raising prices, reducing employment and reducing the generation of income. Finally, to the extent that firms “go underground,” refrain from starting up, go out of business, or evade taxes, the government loses revenue. A number of modifications in the tax regime are suggested in order to overcome its weaknesses. These changes could help the sector to make a more valuable contribution to Cuba in terms of employment and income generation, increased production at lower real costs and prices, and increased tax collection.
Static and dynamic effects of Mercosur. The case of the footwear sector
The static effects of trade creation or diversion are generally held to be the essential variable for evaluating the costs and benefits of regional integration. However, it is the effects of a dynamic nature that provide the most convincing arguments in favour of integrating economies rather than opening them up unilaterally. The difficulties involved in measuring these effects make it necessary to isolate aspects that can provide a basis for analysing the changes undergone by the different production sectors and the consequences of these for the levels and types of industrial organization, business strategies, technological modernization and the regional dynamic, among other things. The footwear sector is very useful when it comes to analysing the effects of subregional integration, as it is a sector that displays rising trade flows within and outside the area, with small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) playing an important role. It forms part of a larger production chain, and its competitiveness depends on systemic factors.
Restructuring in manufacturing: Case studies of Chile, Mexico and Venezuela
The economies of Latin America have undergone important transformations during the past years. Yet, while there have been many studies on the macroeconomic changes that have taken place in Latin America, studies on the microeconomic changes are relatively scarce. The purpose of this paper is to provide evidence that leads to a better understanding of how firms respond to new circumstances. The research on Latin American manufacturing firms presented here shows that the new state of the economic environment has led to a substantial change in firms’ behaviour. Innovative firms have adopted flexible forms of behaviour and are upgrading their production and marketing capabilities, and they have introduced significant changes in terms of vertical integration, input procurement, technological innovation, incentive pay systems and management techniques, training, subcontracting, distribution and retailing. At least for the most innovative consumer goods manufacturing firms, their core activities have shifted from being mainly concerned with production to combining the manufacture of goods with their distribution, and often also the distribution of other domestic and imported goods as well. This provides them with a better chance of simultaneously increasing their profits and defending their market share. Finally, the investigation also showed that uncertainty surrounding economic policy leads to a substantial decrease in investment by firms. Such uncertainty explains why more firms do not change, or why they do not change faster. It has a twofold negative effect on entrepreneurs’ decisions to modernize their firms: they are uncertain about what they should do, as well as about the sustainability of the economic policy. There is therefore an important role for policies that redound in programmes that seek to encourage firms to upgrade. At the same time, it must be stressed that the most important role for policy is that of creating a stable economic environment in which firms can plan long-term investment.
Technological change and industrial dynamics in Latin America
Static and dynamic impacts of MERCOSUR: The case of the pharmaceutical sector
This article analyses the impact of MERCOSUR on the pharmaceutical sector. It concludes, among other things, that the sector suffered strong impacts, both static and dynamic, as a result of the integration process. From the static point of view, it may be observed that integration has given rise to a marked increase in intrazonal trade, which reflects the existence of a substantial trade creation process in MERCOSUR. From the dynamic point of view, the outstanding aspect is the increasing interest in regaining a place in the markets of Argentina and Brazil shown by transnational corporations since the integration process. This process, together with the changes in the regulations on medical patents, has given rise to big changes in the strategies and positions of laboratories of domestic origin.
The Latin American regional market: the project and the reality
The purpose of the present article is to supply sonic background data for a redefinition of the objectives, methods and instruments of Latin American integration: a restatement of the case which the author considers an indispensable requisite for restoring vitality to die movement. In his opinion, Latin American ideas on integration have unfortunately clung too fast to theories whose validity for our societies is slight, and have attempted to keep in step with experiences in industrial countries which are remote from the realities of under-development. On the basis of the region’s own experiences and of clearer conceptions of what integration can he expected to offer, it is possible to inquire into which styles or patterns are technically suitable and which of them may be viable for Latin America.
Prevention or repression? The false dilemma of citizen security
There is a marked contrast between the growing sense of insecurity among the population and the absence of consolidated statistics that would allow the phenomenon to be measured more objectively. This article seeks to make a contribution to the knowledge of the situation of citizen insecurity affecting the region, taking a comparative view based on the limited and not always reliable information available and looking at the problem from various standpoints, both social and economic. The authors begin by examining some manifestations of criminal violence in the 1990s, especially in urban areas, after which they review the most important theories on the study of violence, the profiles of victims and attackers, traditional and emerging forms of delinquency, the frequent relation between violence and unemployment, the economic cost of violence and delinquency, and the main policies adopted to deal with them. They then go on to examine the measures taken in the region with regard to citizen security, which have shown the need to use more integral forms of prevention (primary and secondary) and control for dealing with criminal violence and to consolidate the systems of crime statistics of the region in order to be able to identify the factors with the greatest incidence on criminal violence and the less visible forms taken by the latter.
Structural changes and productivity in Latin American industry, 1970-1996
This article analyses the structural changes in Latin American industry, which speeded up in the 1990s with the consolidation in the region of the external openness programmes, the deregulation of many markets, and the privatization of major sectors of industrial activity which had previously been dominated by State enterprises. The branches of manufacturing which have turned in the best relative performances over the last twenty years are natural resource-based industries producing staple industrial commodities, industries assembling computers, video equipment, television sets or clothing, and the motor industry, which has been given preferential treatment in government economic policy. In contrast, industries producing labour-intensive final goods, those making intensive use of technological knowledge and new product design engineering, or those producing heavy capital goods have been losing relative weight. The pattern of production specialization and the places occupied in world markets for manufactures have clearly been changing, with greater emphasis on utilization of the natural comparative advantages of the region (i.e., its abundant natural resources) or on sectors which have been given special treatment in industrial policy. The article explores the behaviour of the Latin American industrial structure in terms of productivity, comparing it with that of the developed countries. Using the case of the United States as a reference universe, it estimates the labour productivity gap with respect to that country and evaluates the performance of countries and industrial branches in the region as a function of that parameter.
How domestic violence came to be viewed as a public issue and policy object
This article analyses the process whereby domestic violence in Chile became a subject of open discussion and a public issue included in the institutional agenda of the Executive and the Legislature, giving rise to preventive programmes against such violence and public services for aiding its victims, together with the adoption of a law against intra-family violence in 1994. The analysis highlights the dynamic and complex nature of the process, whose course and results were not and could not be determined a priori. Public issues do not exist in their own right, as purely objective phenomena, but are constructed by actors who operate in different settings, exchanging and confronting discourses based on various frames of interpretation. Several different phases may be distinguished in the process, depending on the features and opportunities offered by the political and institutional system, the different types of actors involved, their organizational resources, the structure of the links they establish with each other, and the frame of interpretation that guides what the actors do. Seen from this standpoint, the emergence of cases of violence as a public issue is at the same time the story of the establishment of women as valid social subjects, their organizations, their strategies for mobilizing the issue in different public contexts, and the spread of new types of discourse and proposals on gender-related matters.
Reflections on development financing
This article sets forth some reflections on the position of the region’s countries and the different segments of their domestic financial structures in the international financial system. In the light of the financial globalization taking place in Latin America, it considers the circumstances of the largest countries in the region, looking beyond the stylized arguments of conventional wisdom to analyse different factors influencing the financial situation: sovereignty risk, financial globalization, the degree of financial integration, the cost of capital and the burden of country risk premiums, the link between sovereign risk and fiscal solvency and the consequences of segmented integration. Consideration is then given to courses of action that could reduce country risk. In addition, the role of the different institutional sectors in generating savings is analysed, and the main trends of financial intermediation in the region are considered: banking concentration, the increased involvement of foreign organizations and the role of the public-sector banking system in the circumstances that now prevail.
Regional Planning: What can we do before midnight strikes?
Nowadays, regional planning at the national level is present in most attempts at social change both in developed and developing countries. The author criticizes the lack of a suitable methodology for conducting the planning process at the level of any given region, emphasizes the limitations, deriving from the degree of openness and relative smallness of the regions, as regards their impact on decision-making, and proposes a process of regional planning which gives prominence to the political aspects associated with the strengthening of regional bargaining power both with the central government and with other institutions outside the region. In proposing a process of “negotiated” planning, the author puts the case for utilizing this process as an instrument for strengthening the democratic structure of society.
The potential for hub ports on the Pacific coast of South America
The external trade of a country is closely linked with its geographical location, with the transport services that cover the distance to markets, and the ports through which that trade passes. Recent advances in maritime transport, the growing international economic integration, and the privatization of ports in the countries on the Pacific coast of South America have given rise to expectations that ports could be developed that concentrate both domestic cargo and that of neighbouring countries for its subsequent redistribution: what are known as “hub ports”. The main conclusion of the present study is that the potential for hub ports on the Pacific coast of South America is very limited. In the past, countries tried to prevent the foreign trade of their neighbours from using their ports to gain some kind of commercial benefit. Now, however, the situation has been reversed, and ports compete with each other for the trade of neighbouring countries. In itself, this competition is positive, but the problem is that in many cases it has been raised to a political level which has turned simple competition between ports into international competition between hypothetical future “hub ports”. In view of the low degree of probability that the establishment of such ports on the west coast of South America will be a success, it might be more advisable to seek greater regional coordination of transport policies and of investments in port and land transport infrastructure, in order to promote integration between the countries of the Atlantic and Pacific coasts of South America.
Social protection for the poor in Latin America
Confronted with recurrent macroeconomic shocks, governments in Latin America and the Caribbean have increasingly been concerned about establishing or strengthening systems of social protection and safety net programmes. The goal of these programmes is to help mitigate the impact of shocks on the poor before they occur, and to help the poor cope with the shocks once they have occurred. In this paper, we focus on publicly funded or mandated safety nets functioning as risk-coping mechanisms. The paper reviews the characteristics of a good safety net, in comparison with the main types of safety nets currently in place, and finds in general that no single programme meets all of the criteria in terms of efficiency and effectiveness, although some are better than others. Finally, what has been the actual record in terms of protecting the poor through targeted public spending during crises? The paper finds that because of fiscal constraints during a crisis, social spending is often pro-cyclical when ideally it should be counter-cyclical. Ironically enough, social protection spending itself does not appear to be protected.
Foreign capital inflows and macroeconomic policies
In recent years, a number of countries of the region have gained renewed access to international financial markets, thus passing abruptly from a situation of relative scarcity of external resources to one of abundance. This situation has given rise to considerable pressures on certain key variables of their economies, especially the real exchange rate and interest rates.
Public policies and the competitiveness of agricultural exports
Technological change and structuralist analysis
This article analyses the approach which ECLAC has taken to the subject of technology. In this respect, the author identifies two different periods. The first starts with the inception of ECLAC and continues up to the 1970s. This period, during which efforts focused on achieving Latin America’s industrialization, essentially by means of import substitution, was characterized by what (he author terms “technological passivity” on the part of the relevant agents and of mainstream economic thought in the region.
Social sciences and social reality in Central America
The poverty and weakness of Central America, combined with its potential strategic importance in world politics, have made this region extremely vulnerable to external intellectual and political influences. The result of these influences has been national political processes guided by European notions of Conservatism, Liberalism and Socialism, and a social sciences tradition that is trapped in the intellectual ethos of its mid-nineteenth century European precursors. This article argues that the Eurocentric theoretical orientation dominating Central American social sciences ignores the fact that the relation between time and space that conditioned the evolution of Europe is qualitatively different from that which has influenced the political evolution of Central America since 1492.
The informal sector and poverty in Latin America
Informal economic activities are an important source of jobs in the region. The question as to how this phenomenon should be interpreted and the nature of its im plications are, however, a subject of controversy. Some analysts regard the existence of the inform al economy as a consequence of insufficient economic growth; they contend that it represents a survival strategy and, as such, an involuntary refuge for the poor. Others argue that it is the result of changes in the labour market brought about by government regulation and see it as offering attractive job alternatives that may yield a higher income than many wage-earning positions.
Changes in the urban female labour market
This article seeks to make an orderly summary of the information on urban female labour in Latin America in the 1990s and thus make a contribution to an updated diagnosis of the female labour market to help serve in the formulation of policies for women. It looks at the past evolution of fem ale labour, analyses the effects of the crisis of the early 1980s on this sector of labour, and reviews the changes that have taken place in it, which have undermined the validity of some myths on this subject. It also looks at some critical aspects of female labour, such as income, occupational segm entation, the segregated incorporation of women into jobs involving new technology, and the reduction of the stability of female employment, as reflected in the increase in homeworkers and own-account workers.
Price elasticity of Central American agricultural exports
The economies of the Central American countries (Costa Rica, El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras, Nicaragua) are largely dependent on four major traditional export products: bananas, coffee, cotton and sugar. The share of these products in total Central American exports, which is still close to 50%, only started to decline in the late 1980s. This paper explores the determinants of these four products’ production trends, and the importance of non-price-related economic and social factors and of man-made and natural disruptions is fully acknowledged. However, an attempt is made to use the ECLAC-Mexico database to estimate the supply price elasticities for the four products over the 1960-1990 period, testing simplified linear regression models which include only output prices as the relevant explanatory variables.
Open regionalism and economic integration
Women’s formal education: Achievements and obstacles
An examination of women’s education in the region leads to apparently contradictory conclusions: on the one hand, genuine progress has been made in terms of coverage and performance, justifying the assertion that the region is making headway towards achieving equal opportunities of access where they do not already exist and that the situation will continue to improve. On the other hand, however, an analysis of the data also brings out less positive factors that warrant continued concern about this issue.
Globalization and restructuring the energy sector in Latin America
This article analyses the main manifestations of the globalization process and its implications in terms of the restructuring of energy markets. The reforms now being undertaken by the countries of the region are being pursued within the context of an economic paradigm with ramifications at the international level which assigns high priority to the liberalization and/or privatization of public utilities, and this, in turn, can be expected to engender new savings/investment strategies based on the relatively more stable nature of income flows from energy activities.
Financial repression and the Latin American finance pattern
This article presents a critique of the theory of financial repression, in place of which it offers an alternative approach to development financing, based mainly on the Keynesian tradition. The concept of financial repression refers to the situation of a market suffering from institutional obstacles, both in terms of economic policy and adm inistrative aspects, which prevent it from attaining an equilibrium position and thus jeopardize the rationality of the resource allocation process.
Potential and limits of health management reform in Chile
Against a background of increased expenditure and improved equity, this reform of public health management in Chile, set in the context of a dual health system, aims to consolidate a cost advantage over the private sector. Emphasis has been placed on the distinction between the regulatory, financial and supply functions in the public sector, and a relative opposition of interests between them has been encouraged, with a view to generating quasi-markets. The “management commitments” entered into between the Ministry of Health and the Health Services mark a departure from the strategy of resource allocation guided by historical budgets and make results the decisive factor of funding.
Capital movements and external financing
This article explores the causes, consequences, magnitude and forms of a phenomenon which is of fundamental importance in the current scene and has enormous implications for the Latin American economics: the growing pace of international capital movements. Many billions of dollars are shifted across national borders by satellite, and a small part of this amount has become the basic element in Latin America’s external financing. This financial globalization has its roots in the accumulation of enormous tied liquid surpluses, the generalized liberalization of capital accounts after the collapse of the Bretton Woods frontiers, and the impact of the technological revolution in the fields of informatics and communications.
Transnational corporations and structural changes in industry In Argentina, Brazil, Chile and Mexico
The central focus of this article is on the role played by transnational corporations in the industrial realignment of Argentina, Brazil, Chile and Mexico between the end of the import substitution stage and the early 1990s. Based on recently published studies dealing with the sweeping changes occurring in Latin America’s manufacturing sector following the region’s economic crisis and liberalization process, a computer programme developed by the ECLAC Division of Production, Productivity and Management has been used to examine the changes that have taken place in the sector’s production structure (sectoral composition and efficiency) and its linkages with the global economy.
Post-conflict peace-building: A challenge for the United Nations
The multidisciplinary peace-keeping and post-conflict peace-building (PCPB) operations of today have imposed on the United Nations a multifaceted and complex role, comprising both verification and good offices functions in a wide variety of areas. This has put tremendous pressure on the human and financial resources of the Organization. As a result, many flaws in the United Nations system have been brought to light, such as the inadequate coordination that exists between the different bodies of the Organization and its inability to address problems associated with peace and development in a rigorous, integrated, transparent, coherent and consistent way.
Panama and Central American economic integration
This article looks at the benefits that Panama could derive from its possible integration with the countries of the Central American Common Market (CACM). First of all, Panama’s production structure is analysed in terms of the phenomenon known as the “Dutch disease”: this reveals the de-industrializing effect that the booms in the services sector have had on the economy. An examination is then made of the advantages that Panama could derive from gradual integration with the CACM countries in terms of intra-industry exports, promotion of investments, competition and modernization of production, and it is asserted that these benefits do not exist, on a reciprocal basis, in a scheme based on unilateral trade openness.
The privatization of public water utilities
Latin America has kept in step with the worldwide trend towards the privatization of public utilities. Its motivation for doing so stems from a number of factors: an economic philosophy, its quest for greater efficiency, macroeconomic situations, debt-equity swaps, decisions to bring private capital into the management of public utilities during times of economic crisis, and others. This article analyses the characteristics and components of public utilities, the differences existing between one utility and another (particularly in terms of their capital/revenue ratio), the rigidity of supply and investment, the possibilities of giving consumers a choice, the concept of economies of scale and how it ties in with the notion of monopolies, and the legal implications of monopolistic systems.
The contributions of applied anthropology to peasant development
The present surge of interest in participative rural development projects based on peasant communities differs from similar past experiences in that it forms part of a broader tendency to decentralize social management, to enhance the role of the beneficiaries of social policies, and to give them a bigger say in their implementation. In order to avoid repeating the failures of past decades in programmes designed to reduce rural poverty, it is necessary to incorporate elements of modem applied anthropology in programmes for the training of extension workers and in the explanatory models of specialists formulating rural development projects.
Central America: Macroeconomic performance and social financing
The analysis of social area financing in small economies has taken on great importance in recent years with the growing recognition of the mutual links between economic and social processes. Investment in human capital is seen as fundamental for attaining the competitiveness demanded by participation in world trade. In Central America, the socio-political situation has given rise to growing interest in studying social area financing and in gaining a knowledge of the economic possibilities there will be in coming years for assigning resources to social activities.
Globalization and loss of autonomy by the fiscal, banking and monetary authorities
The idea that globalization impairs the sovereignty of the modem nation-State is increasingly accepted in some academic, government and international circles. Currently, there is generalized concern over the progressive erosion of national authorities’ leeway for making decisions on matters of internal interest independently of outside influences. This perception has reached its extreme among those who feel that globalization has transformed the nation-State into a dysfunctional entity in a world without frontiers. It is understandable that a consensus should have grown up around this thesis, in view of its general nature and in particular because of the conceptual flexibility with which the notions of globalization and sovereignty are usually treated in some professional circles.
Quality management promotion to improve competitiveness
Hie author aims to demonstrate the importance of quality issues in national strategies for increased productivity and competitiveness in Latin America. Quality is an important factor in today’s increasingly globalized and liberalized markets, and the application of quality management techniques is therefore considered to make a positive contribution to the competitive performance of countries, economic sectors and individual organizations. Since competitiveness contributes to sustainable development, the widespread diffusion and implementation of quality management seems desirable from a national point of view.
Institutions and growth: Can human capital be a link?
This paper attempts to provide a sounder link between institutions and economic growth. It does so by i) identifying those institutions which might matter the most with respect to economic performance, ii) providing a rationale as to why they might matter, and iii) confronting that rationale with some systematic empirical evidence. We postulate that the central and common characteristic of relevant institutions is that they give agents a voice, a stake in the system.
The strategies pursued by Mexican firms in their efforts to become global players
Almost 60% of the biggest non-financial groups in Mexico carry on at least two types of activities in transnational markets. This article describes and analyses the various internationalization paths and strategies of Mexican firms. This drive for internationalization is taking place against the background of an open export-oriented economy and growing integration with the United States and Canada. There are various national and international factors, as well as others specific to the firms themselves, which influence the strategies chosen and their results.
Public institutions and explicit and implicit environmental policies
In recent years the question of the environment has been increasingly prominent in studies and proposals on the development of the Latin American and Caribbean countries. The serious processes of ecological imbalance in the world, together with numerous disasters and the ongoing loss of natural resources, have given rise to increasing concern over these matters. To a greater or lesser extent, all the governments of the region have tried to strengthen their environmental policies through various legal, technical, institutional and economic measures. Much still needs to be done, however, to correct the existing deficits and ensure that the new measures applied are really efficient and effective.
The evolution of the State’s role In the regulation of land transport
For nearly twenty years, the land transport sector of various Latin American countries has been undergoing highly significant institutional changes, both through the participation of the private sector and through the easing of economic regulations, giving rise to new needs for regulation of the market in general and the operating units in particular. The most important changes have taken place in rail and bus transport and in the road transport infrastructure. In the region, these changes took place first of all in Chile and reversed the previous predominance of State intervention associated with a development model which had begun to run out of steam.
Pension system reforms in Latin America: The position of the International organizations
This article analyses the position taken by various international and regional organizations regarding pension system reforms in Latin America. Over the last ten years, these organizations have carried out studies on almost all the Latin American countries (although on only a few in the English-speaking Caribbean), identified and analysed key aspects, compared the reforms made, evaluated their advantages and disadvantages and developed global strategies or sets of desirable features for ideal types of reforms. The author identifies a number of the main alternatives or issues in the social security debate, makes a general classification of the pension system reforms carried out in the region, and after describing a hypothetically universal model he analyses its real viability.
The Mexican peso crisis
In the author’s view, the Mexican financial crisis which erupted at the end of 1994 was not unique, although it did have some special features. Thus, since it could happen again, it would be desirable to gain an in-depth understanding of it. This article therefore analyses the process and underlying causes of the Mexican peso crisis. For this purpose, the author distinguishes three main periods. The first of these extends from the beginning of 1990 up to March 1994, and an analysis is made of the problems that were hatching and the policy options that were available. With regard to the second period -from March 1994 to 20 December of that year- the available options are likewise examined. In the case of the third period, attention is centered on the devaluation and the resulting crisis, and an appraisal is made of the way they were handled.
Regulating the private provision of drinking water and sanitation services
Ever since the 1970s, the governm ents of the region have been transferring public com panies and other State institutions to the private sector in one m anner or another. Privatization has now spread to all sectors of the economy, including drinking water supply and sanitation services. Private sector involvement in the provision of these services offers potentially significant efficiency gains, but it will not, in itself, guarantee lasting welfare improvement unless these services are provided in a competitive market.
The Central Bank and Chilean macroeconomic policy in the 1990s
Free trade agreements and female labour: The chilean situation
This article analyses the relations between economic integration processes, employment and equality of opportunities between men and women. To this end, the case of Chile is considered, where simultaneous processes of internationalization of the economy, the pursuit of economic integration agreements and the growing incorporation of women into the labour force are taking place. The relation between integration agreements and the labour situation of women derives from three factors. Firstly, the new trade flows affect employment and wages, and there may be a differential effect by sex if the female labour force is concentrated in particular, sectors of production.
The North-South dimension of the environmental and cleaner technology Industries
The environment industry, which includes a wide range of products and services relating to the monitoring, treatment, control and management of industrial and domestic pollution, has grown rapidly during the 1980s and 1990s as a response to environmental regulations. Due to the relatively early application of these regulations in the United States, Europe and Japan, these areas have become competitive producers and exporters of environmental products and services. As the industrial sector has developed, environmental awareness has been raised and competition and international trade in the environment industry have expanded.
Equity, foreign investment and international competitiveness
Is the degree of competitiveness of countries independent of their degree of inequality? Is competitiveness only a question of microeconomic and sectoral efficiency, of the real exchange rate, or is it also a social question? So far, the specialized literature has ignored the problem of equity in the determination of countries’ competitiveness. It has then not been able to fully explain the observed competitiveness, however. In this article, equity is incorporated into the production function and also into investors’ decisions in a world of perfect mobility of capital.
A development strategy founded on natural resource-based production clusters
This article contends that the rapid development of Latin America and the Caribbean - a region rich in natural resources- will depend on how fast it learns to industrialize and process its natural resources and to develop the necessary suppliers of inputs, engineering services and equipment for this. Consequently, this will not be a form of development based on the mere extraction of natural resources, as at present, but rather one based on the processing of such resources and the development of the activities that naturally tend to spring up and concentrate around this base (production complexes or clusters).
Non-agricultural rural employment in Central America
Non-agricultural rural employment accounts for an increasing proportion of total rural employment in Latin America. Its potential for stimulating rural development has been noted, but it has also been analysed as a focal point of poverty. This article considers the magnitude and composition of this employment in some of the Central American countries and examines the conditions under which nonagricultural activities may help to improve rural employment and income.
Access to housing and direct housing subsidies: Some Latin American experiences
Tensions in Latin American structural adjustment: Allocation versus distribution
In the economic history of Latin America, a growing population demanded jobs; creating more jobs required industrialization; and industrialization made it necessary to cover a productivity differential. There were two feasible options for this purpose: i) to preserve allocative efficiency and generate a major regressive income redistribution process; or ii) to lose allocative efficiency but leave the distribution of income largely unchanged. Governments chose the latter and built in lasting distortions in the foreign exchange market. Import substitution industrialization ended in stagnation. Increased pressure in the labour market could have driven wages sharply downward, but instead the informal market arose and, thanks to its monopolistically competitive structure, segmented the goods markets and ensured a minimally acceptable form of income distribution.
Fiscal policy and the economic cycle in Chile
This article studies the effect of the stabilization of fiscal expenditure and the anti-cyclical use of taxes as stabilization variables in the Chilean economy, through the calibration of a basic macro-economic model adapted to the actual conditions of that economy. The results show that some 25% of the variability of economic growth could be eliminated by obviating fiscal cyclical impulses through constant growth of public investment and consumption and through anti-cyclical taxes. On the one hand, it is proposed that a system of stabilization of the growth of fiscal expenditure should be established, through a system of rules and degrees of flexibility subject to specific clauses.
Development thinking and policies: The way ahead
This article takes a long-term view of the evolution of development thinking and policies in Latin America and the Caribbean. It begins by looking at the changes in policy formulation trends, noting that the most abrupt changes of this type occurred, first during the period between the wars, and second, in the early 1980s, and although in both cases changes took place which may be considered as swings of the pendulum or phases in a larger picture, they were nevertheless significant. The author then reviews the economic reforms implemented from the 1980s onwards and highlights their common factors, although these cannot be said to belong to a set paradigm, because of the markedly different ways they were applied in the different countries.
The interplay of macro- and microeconomics
First of all, I would like to express my satisfaction at being here in Central America, and to thank our hosts warmly and sincerely for their support. The United Nations in general and the Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean in particular owe a great deal to Costa Rica for its unwavering support over the years, especially since President Jose Figueres Olsen assumed office. Our gratitude is also due to this country for its important contributions to intraregional cooperation and especially to Central American integration. This occasion demonstrates again the unfailingly constructive contribution which President Figueres and his Administration have made to strengthening our relationship of interdependence.
An appraisal of capital goods policy in Argentina
Science and technology policy and the National Innovation System in Argentina
This article looks at the strengths and weaknesses of the policies proposed in the Argentine National Multi-year Science and Technology Plan, 1998-2000, within the conceptual framework of the National Innovation System (NIS) approach. In the light of a severe diagnosis of the weaknesses of Argentine efforts in this field, the new public policies are designed to promote the interaction of the many agents and institutions involved in those efforts, to change the rules governing the allocation of public resources to research, to promote strategic plans and evaluation mechanisms in public bodies in this field, and to induce greater voluntary spending by the private sector through fiscal credits for technological research and development and a Technological Advisers Programme, in order to give better attention to the demands of small and medium-sized enterprises. However, there are very profound and severe shortcomings in the ability of the Argentine financial system to provide finance for longterm investments in intangible assets, in the capacity of the educational system to link up with the needs of the production sector, and in the ability of the scientific institutions to interact with the educational system and the production sector. Although these shortcomings are mentioned in the Plan, they are not given the amount of attention needed to begin to reverse them. The long and frustrating past history of science and technology policies in the country, which have registered more failures than successes, and the partial success of the laissez-faire policy applied in the 1990s, which was considered to be a good policy by most of domestic and foreign big business, militate against the success of the initiatives under way. At the same time, and in spite of its stimulating suggestions, the approach taken by the NIS reflects serious ambiguities in its normative and conceptual aspects which limit its practical applicability.
The United States to the rescue: Financial assistance to Mexico in 1982 and 1995
This article analyses the financial rescue measures taken by the United States in the Mexican payments crises of August 1982 and January 1995. On both occasions, Mexico was on the brink of suspending payments on its external debt, and both times this was avoided thanks to rescue measures. The implications of the two financial rescue programmes were very different, however. The measures taken in August 1982 were followed by a period of many years in which Mexico was practically excluded from private loan markets. In contrast, the 1995 rescue programme was quickly followed by renewed access by Mexico to private capital markets.
The State, the community and society in social development
The World Summit for Social Development, held in Copenhagen on 11 and 12 March 1995, brought up once more the ideals which gave rise to the United Nations at the San Francisco Conference and which have since been reasserted in many forums of the Organization. The maintenance of peace and security, although an irreplaceable element in the peaceful coexistence of nations, was not the only objective of that Conference, however: it also sought to lay the foundations for a form of coexistence which would make possible more harmonious development. The United Nations Charter which emerged from that meeting was the clear expression of a humanistic spirit and of the quest for democratic ideals and values which made human beings the centre of governments’ concern.
Trade policy within the context of the World Trade Organization
This study looks at the main obligations arising from the World Trade Organization and their repercussions on the design of trade policy. First of all, the study analyses the content of the world trade system and the problems it raises, and highlights the fact that, as the number of questions considered expands and an ever-increasing number of policies are brought under international scrutiny, the delicate balance between trade policy and negotiations must be adjusted more and more exactly. It is pointed out that the commitments entered into within the context of the WTO indicate the direction but not the depth of trade reforms in Latin America. Closer analysis of the obligations arising from the WTO shows that they offer substantial leeway.
Military expenditure in Colombia: Macroeconomic and microeconomic aspects
This article analyses defence and security spending (DSS) in Colombia, on the assumption that in order to gain a better idea of the effect of such spending on economic growth and the public finances it would be desirable to analyse its internal composition, since this would make it possible to infer its impact on the production of defence and security. In order to do this, various theories on the repercussions of military expenditure are reviewed and defence and security spending in Colombia is analysed on the basis of information from the Office of the Comptroller-General of the Republic. The efficiency of spending on the armed forces and the National Police is then examined, especially as regards the relations between combat and support and attack and defence, and it is shown that the military forces need to be reorganized. In the conclusions, various ways of securing savings on the defence budget are proposed. The most important of these are connected with personnel management, as payroll expenses represent 73% of total spending. The proposals made in this respect are to modify the system of pay and allowances, increase the retirement age, reduce the number of personnel and restructure the proportions between combat forces and support and administrative personnel.
Indigenous organizations: Rising actors in Latin America
This article analyses the recent increase in the importance of indigenous peoples as political and social actors in the region, reviewing the changes that have taken place in the situation of the indigenous peoples, the relationship between the State and such peoples, the forging of new identities, and cultural changes: questions that are all being reappraised in the light of what has become known as “the ethnic question". The author highlights the existence of a number of leading threads which appear and reappear in the various types of indigenous movements.
Socio-economic structure and crisis of peripheral capitalism
In the present article the author continues and expands the critical analysis of peripheral capitalism which he began in another that was published in the first issue of this Review. His central contention is that in peripheral societies the development process — whereby the accumulation of capital in the form of goods and training of human resources makes it possible to step up the productivity of the labour force and thus to increase the total product— is not carried out with the necessary efficiency at the social and even, in many cases, at the economic level.
Neo-liberal structural reforms in Latin America: The current situation
Latín America is currently undergoing a strategic turnaround with far-reaching implications: from an inward-oriented form of development with heavy State intervention in production and the system of prices, to an outward-oriented development strategy in the context of a free market, with the private sector playing the leading role. This study analyses the seven main reforms associated with this neo-liberal strategy.
Components of an effective environmental policy
Governments now have very wide experience in promoting development and achieving better levels of income by means of macroeconomic and sectoral policies. Nevertheless, their experience is limited and they have not been very successful in guaranteeing the environmental sustainability of the projects they undertake and, thus helping to assure income sources.
Europe 92 and the Latin American economy
This article analyzes the economic effects which the Europe of 1992 could have on the countries of Latin America. It examines the main factors which led to the signing of the Single European Act in 1985, such as the loss of competitiveness of the European economies, the slow recovery of the European Economic Càimmunity (rrc) after the two oil crises, and the rigid politico-institutional system of the Community.
The incorporation of women in development policies
There is an obvious imbalance between the magnitude of women’s contribution to Latin American and Caribbean economies and the scope of actions and policies aimed at women. The same imbalance is seen between women’s contribution and the benefits they receive through their participation in regional development.
