Gender Equality
When sport breaks down walls
On the 9th of November 2019, we celebrated the 30th Anniversary of the Fall of the Berlin Wall, an event which has become a global icon for positive, disruptive change, a symbol of reunification and justice.
Une histoire personnelle
Appelons-la Magda. Le nom est inventé, mais l’histoire est vraie. Elle est née au Lesotho il y a 35 ans. Sa vie illustre le fléau que subissent les femmes en termes de violences physiques, sexuelles et psychologiques.
Le moment est venu dexprimer notre solidarité envers les Haïtiennes
Je n’oublierai jamais le moment où le séisme a frappé Dodoma, dans mon pays natal la Tanzanie, en 2002, lorsque j’étais membre du Parlement. N’ayant aucune idée de ce qu’il fallait faire dans ces caslà, je suis sortie instinctivement en courant. Si j’ai eu de la chance que les secousses aient causé peu de dégâts, j’ai compris combien nous étions fragiles. Le séisme qui a dévasté Haïti a ravivé ces souvenirs avec force et mes pensées sont allées vers mes collègues ainsi que vers le peuple haïtien qui ont été profondément touchés.
Interview: The legacy of Giovanni Falcone: Never lower your head, be brave and always fulfil your commitments until the end
Your brother was a great judge and statesman, among the first to understand the real dimensions of the mafia phenomenon and the importance of judicial cooperation. His work and legacy have helped to change the strategies to combat organized crime. His path has been defined by the spirit of sacrifice and the awareness of risks. He was born and he lived in Sicily and was surrounded by forms of acceptance and resignation caused by the Mafia. What was his relationship with his land? Can you tell us about how he developed his strength and determination in Sicily?
Women and prevention of violent extremism: Does it work — and if so, how?
Innovative approaches in countering violent extremism are not only a question of philosophy, but also of pragmatism. We need a new dialogue to strategize how to establish a consensus/springboard from which to reinforce local, national and global security. We don’t need to analyse what has not worked, but actually focus on analysing what is working.
研究: “这次疫情暴发将成为导火索”
广角. 女性重构的新世界: 大流行病如是说
观点: 影响历史进程的那些微生物和病毒
全球摸底调: 教育: 史无前例的危机
The impact of foreign direct investment on gender inequality in India
This paper examines the effect of foreign direct investment (FDI) on female employment and wages in India. Using both household-level and plant-level data, it estimates the impact of industry-level FDI inflows on employment, wages and the gender wage gap for skilled and unskilled female workers. Further, it estimates whether there are any “cultural transfers” or spillovers in terms of gender norms from more gender-equal countries through this FDI. In order to estimate this, a weighted industry-level Gender Inequality Index (GII) is created. The main findings are that although FDI leads to an increase in employment of unskilled female workers, it worsens the gender wage gap. Further, there is no strong evidence of cultural spillovers to skilled female workers. This may be explained by the fact that multinational enterprises choose to adopt local institutions in order to be successful in developing-country markets, thereby losing some of their ownership advantages.
Articles: Introduction to the Transnational Corporations special issue on multinational enterprises and gender equality
Foreign direct investment (FDI) and multinational enterprises (MNEs) are important sources of financing for developing countries. In this context, the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) has a long track-record of looking at both spillovers from FDI and gender equality. The policy study on investment by transnational corporations and gender provided a preliminary review of the academic literature on the impact of foreign investment on gender policy and practice, focusing on the wage and employment effects, and the related potential for women’s empowerment (UNCTAD, 2014). In addition, the 2020 World Investment Report (UNCTAD, 2020a) describes that the world’s leading multinational enterprises are increasing their gender equality reporting and policies, contributing to broader female representation and positive development impacts. Finally, several of the papers in this special issue served as background research for the UNCTAD (forthcoming) policy report on The International Transmission of Gender Policies and Practices: The Role of Multinational Enterprises. This original academic research was presented at an expert group meeting in May 2020, which brought together researchers, practitioners, and policymakers to discuss tangible policy recommendations and development impacts, while formally validating the quality of the research as part of the review process.
Can multinational firms promote gender equality? The role of labour mobility
A long and well-established literature exists on the role of multinational enterprises (MNEs) in transferring technology around the globe, enhancing local productivity. However, we know very little about the impact of foreign direct investment (FDI) and multinational enterprises on gender policy and practice. In this research, we focus on the role of MNEs in potentially promoting female empowerment and gender equality in Brazil. First, the research performs a descriptive exercise on the gender composition and gender earnings gaps at MNEs versus domestic firms. Then, we ask whether workers moving from multinational to domestic firms can transfer information about gender practice, by exploring the relationship across domestic firms with various proportions of workers with previous experience in a multinational. Unfortunately, despite the many theoretical reasons to expect MNEs to support and transfer best practice in gender policy, these ideas are not borne out in the data. Multinational firms employ fewer women and exhibit higher gender earnings gaps than their domestic firm counterparts. For this reason, it is no surprise that domestic firms with high shares of former MNE workers are not different from domestic firms with fewer former MNE workers in terms of gender policy and practice. Our work emphasizes the need for domestic policy to enhance the status of women in the economy and the international community to support best practice in gender policy across all types of firms.
Foreign direct investment and gender inequality: evidence from South Africa
We study an often-overlooked factor behind gender inequality: globalization, in particular, foreign direct investment (FDI). Building on a growing literature that studies the impact of trade and FDI on gender inequality, we test whether foreign-owned firms exhibit a different gender wage gap (GWG) than firms with domestic ownership, using unique South African administrative matched employer-employee data. We find that the unconditional GWG is substantially smaller in foreign-owned firms than in firms with domestic ownership. We also find that for foreign-owned firms this difference is reversed once we control for a large set of fixed effects. In our preferred specification, foreign-owned firms have a larger GWG of about 2.4 percentage points. The share of women employed in foreign firms is lower than in firms with domestic ownership, in contrast to similar studies, which may indicate an underlying inequality in opportunities for women within a developing country context.
UNCTAD Insights: The role of multinational and trading enterprises in employment and the gender pay gap: Evidence from Finland
This paper constructs and analyses a set of novel indicators on gender equality in the business sector, which focus on multinational enterprises and foreign traders in Finland. The descriptive analysis reveals large differences in the share of women and men employed in the best paying professions, especially in multinationals. Dynamic analysis shows that foreign investment typically results in pay increases for males, while this is not true for women. These disparities are strongest among managers and professionals working in the most profitable firms. A blueprint is provided for linking business statistics and social statistics to enable analyses of gender inequalities in the labour market.
The role of regulation and MNEs in ensuring equal opportunities for women
Government policy and private sector practice have the ability to spread gender equality, which can have an impact on growth and development. Over the past years, an upsurge has been observed in trade agreements that carve out space for gender issues in their agendas. The same is not true for international investment treaties. Foreign direct investment inflows can lead to more opportunities for women in the job market but may also exacerbate disparities. This paper aims to address and compare the role and effect of gender provisions in trade and investment agreements, and to shed light on additional policies that may be needed to ensure that governments and multinational enterprises address gender constraints.
Insider’s advantage: when foreign firms do not capture opportunity in the local labour market
Previous studies have argued that, relative to local firms, multinational firms may have an “outsider’s advantage” in hiring women. Using a large data set of executives in the countries of the Gulf Cooperation Council, in a region with some of the lowest rates of female labour force participation in the world, I present new evidence of a setting in which foreign firms do not capture opportunity in the local labour market. I find that foreign firms, on average, are not more likely than local firms to hire female executives and are less likely to place women into top management roles. I propose that foreign firms may have fewer social networks and resources, or lack “insider’s advantage”, relative to local firms for recruiting women into executive positions.
Foreign investment and female employment in Viet Nam
This paper investigates how the interplay between foreign direct investment (FDI) and the availability of technology affects labour market outcomes for women in Viet Nam. Using household surveys, we explore the relationship between industrial exposure to FDI, access to technology, and employment and wages. We find that FDI is associated with increases in employment and wages by more in hightechnology areas of the country. In areas of the country with weak technology, foreign investment is associated with lower employment and lower wages, particularly for men. Together, these results highlight the importance of absorptive capacity; that is, to truly benefit from foreign investment, the domestic economy needs a sound education system and established technology. We also find that an equal increase in foreign investment in high-tech provinces is associated with larger increases in top wages for men than for women. In general, these results suggest that foreign investment may be associated with a rising gender wage gap at the high end of the wage distribution.
Women empowerment, supply chain linkages and FDI: Evidence from Bangladesh
This paper studies foreign direct investment spillovers on the gender-related labour market practice of domestic firms, based on a unique firm-to-firm data set of Bangladesh’s textiles and garment sectors. The paper looks at the female employment of domestic firms that are directly and indirectly related to foreign- owned firms through supply chain linkages. These domestic firms are either the local suppliers or customers of foreign-owned firms, or they share local suppliers and customers with foreign-owned firms. The estimates show that domestic firms related to foreign-owned firms have significantly more female administrative workers, but not necessarily more female non-administrative workers, owing to the former participating in more firm-to-firm interactions.
Foreign acquisitions and female employment in manufacturing firms: An empirical analysis for Chile
This paper analyses the effect of foreign ownership on female employment using micro-level data from the Chilean Manufacturing Survey. Particularly, it examines whether foreign-acquired firms hire proportionately more female workers than domestic firms. To control for the possible endogeneity of the foreign acquisition decision, we use propensity score matching combined with a difference-in- differences approach. In addition, we compare firms operating in the same industry-year. Our results show that foreign ownership increases the share of female workers within the firm. One year after acquisition the share of female workers is 1.64 percentage points higher in acquired firms than in non-acquired firms, and this figure increases to 3.55 percentage points two years after acquisition. When we separate female workers into skilled and unskilled categories, we observe that the positive effect of foreign acquisition is present only for skilled women. One year after acquisition, the share of skilled women is 4.60 percentage points higher in acquired firms than in non-acquired ones, and two years after acquisition this figure increases to 6.63 percentage points. We also present evidence that foreign acquisition increases the share of skilled women only when the acquired firm was not an exporter before its acquisition, supporting Becker’s (1957) theory on taste- based discrimination.
Evidence-based policymaking in a VUCA world
In a volatile, uncertain, complex and ambiguous (VUCA) world, responses by governments to global shocks will vary in substance and rate of success. We argue that policymakers can make better decisions when high-quality evidence is incorporated into an evidence-based policymaking (EBP) process. To generate high-quality evidence for analysing shock events, researchers should use event analysis, a methodological approach for exploring research questions such as the timing, frequency and patterns of events and their antecedents and consequences. We discuss four types of research methods used in event analysis and their relative appropriateness for analysing different categories of events. In particular, we argue that one method – the event study – is well suited for analysing crises, i.e. shock events that involve high threat, short decision-making time and surprise. We conclude that understanding and using the tools of event analysis is key to successful EBP in a VUCA world.
Key Success Factors of SME Internationalisation: A Cross-Country Perspective
This book is a valuable reference document for the study of the evolution of contemporary socioeconomic life, marked by radical changes in structures, behaviours, methods of production and consumption, and rules of the social game. The current changes are of a “revolutionary” nature and thus make possible the vision of the future, which is necessary to decide on investments (material or immaterial). The uncertain dominates. Optimistic thinkers or actors believe that insofar as nothing is safe, everything is possible. But we still have to understand what is desirable, necessary or possible, because opportunities and risks are linked. The analysis of key success factors that are, or have been, actually operational is therefore of the highest interest.
Overcoming institutional voids in the home country for internationalization: an exploratory examination of institutional strategies of Indian MNEs
This study draws upon the institution-based view to examine the role of market and non-market institutional strategies of multinational enterprises from emerging markets (EMNEs) in shaping their decisions on outward foreign direct investment (OFDI) (decision to engage in OFDI and volume of investment). The proposed conceptual framework is tested on the OFDI decisions of listed Indian firms during the period 2008–2018. The results of random effects logistic regression and tobit regression provide robust evidence for the positive impact of institutional substitution and institutional signaling strategy on the decision to engage in OFDI as well as the volume of investment. An institutional borrowing strategy affects only the decision to engage in OFDI, whereas an internalization strategy does not help EMNEs while internationalizing. The study contributes to the literature on institutional voids and institutional escapism by identifying the strategies that facilitate overseas expansion. It adds to the EMNE literature, which has focused lately on explaining the role of non-market strategies in internationalization. The results of the study indicate the need for policy initiatives geared towards filling information voids, strengthening legal systems and development of credit markets.
Green lemons: overcoming adverse selection in the green bond market
As the green bond market continues to develop and assume a critical role as a post-pandemic vehicle for supporting a balanced economic rebuild and credible transition efforts, policymakers must reassess the current disclosure regime. This paper derives findings from Bayesian games to demonstrate that the prevailing labelling regime for green bonds is susceptible to the adverse selection problem; due to informational asymmetries, allocative inefficiencies arising from capital misallocation to inherently “non-green” bonds may ensue. To prevent the erosion of confidence in the market segment and support the potential of impact finance instruments to affect positive social and environmental change, this paper draws on established game theory frameworks to inform recommendations for policyled solutions to uphold the market’s credibility. These recommendations concern the integration of a regulatory infrastructure, a centralized ongoing audit under an “exogenously costly” regime and the introduction of a clearer course for legal recourse against issuers that mislabel bonds.
Harnessing power within global value chains for sustainable development
Global value chains (GVCs) are a powerful vehicle through which multinational enterprises (MNEs) can help address the grand challenges that humanity faces. But optimally utilizing GVCs for sustainability requires fundamental changes in corporate behaviour. In this paper we expound the concept of MNE economic power within GVCs and discuss needed changes for MNE business models to fill governance gaps. We debate the renewed role of public governance to promote social and environmental standards along GVCs and outline policies that governments should adopt to help MNEs and lead firms alter their business model.
Who owns international business?
International business in the past century has largely been the domain of large multinational enterprises and banks, as well as small exporting and importing companies. The scope of international business activity has grown in recent years, and today there are many State-owned companies involved in international business activities, as well as financial investors rather than only industrial or commercial companies undertaking foreign direct investment (FDI). Government policy toward international business has largely been supportive since the 1990s, while concerns have arisen particularly in regard to the activities of State-owned enterprises and also the activities of non-traditional investors such as investment funds. To achieve the greatest benefits from FDI and trade, governments need to understand which companies are making the key decisions in global value chains and to collaborate in rule-setting and in guiding companies to pursue desirable activities and to limit non-business goal-seeking.
A reassessment of UNCTAD’s transnationality indices in the digital economy
This research note reassesses UNCTAD’s transnationality indices in light of recent economic trends that are quickly changing the international investment landscape: the digital economy, the new industrial revolution and the resulting asset-light international business models. The recent international “Agreement on a Two-Pillar Solution to Address the Tax Challenges Arising from the Digitalisation of the Economy” through the Base Erosion Profit Shifting project emphasizes the importance of fully understanding and correctly interpreting the implications of digitalization for investment and development policy. The analysis shows that UNCTAD’s internationalization indices are still able to capture relevant structural changes but could benefit from several fine-tuning options to allow a clearer interpretation and consequently a better elaboration of policy advice. Relevant policy areas include international taxation, as suggested by the analysis of the FDI lightness index, but also employment and more generally development strategies of host economies.
Exports, trade costs and FDI entry: evidence from Japanese firms
Why does aggregate foreign direct investment (FDI) fall with distance? We conjecture that high trade costs adversely affect FDI entry decisions in a dynamic setting, even when controlling for previous export experience in foreign markets. We test this hypothesis using Japanese firm-level data for the period of 1995–2018, and find that the probability of FDI entry decreases with distance. We conclude that trade costs limit a firm’s ability to assess foreign market uncertainty. As a result, a firm may exit a foreign market before realizing the potential profitability and never establish an affiliate there. This result is highly relevant for policymakers, as it proves that trade liberalization and FDI facilitation policies may reinforce each other, resulting in a compound effect for both exports and FDI.
Investing in sustainable infrastructure: new directions for international business research
In the global economy today, there is both a supply-side push of large amounts of stimulus funding being directed at infrastructure investment and a corresponding demand-pull, with nearly all of the countries in the world committing themselves to the Sustainable Development Goals and to the transition to a net zero economy. In the energy sector, the pressure to rapidly increase the proportion of renewable capacity, primarily wind and solar, has created unprecedented opportunities for investment, but it also raises concerns about the availability of project finance investors to execute all of these projects, particularly in developing countries. We discuss three areas of future research that address the causes and remedies for such capacity constraints, namely, the structuring of project finance investment, demonstration effects, and the role of technological complementarities and leapfrogging in developing countries.
International venturing and investment: global citizens and golden visas
Countries attract foreign investors, “entrants”, to invest and venture by employing policy programmes and marketing strategies. Country attractiveness for foreign investors relates to international competitiveness. Instruments building a formal status, such as golden visas and citizenship, are used to attract individual foreign investors and their families. These are often cosmopolitan people, i.e. global citizens but also global diasporans. They contribute to the economy, ideas and transnational entrepreneurial ecosystems. These policy instruments are criticized partly due to missing legitimacy, partly due to concerns about geopolitics and international crime. However, diasporic investors manifest different motivations and commitments, making them particular. This study examines what kind of investor programmes are offered to different foreign migrant investors and whether they address diasporic ties. It presents a country comparison of investor policy pathways towards citizenship. It contributes to the literature on migrant investment and policymaking.
World Investment Forum 2021: insights from the Academic Track and a future research agenda
Home-country export regulations, credit markets, and corruption: implications for different types of internationalization
Direct exporting activities and outward foreign direct investment (OFDI) are two types of internationalization that differ in firms’ opportunities, resources and risks. We study home-country institutional factors for internationalization and empirically investigate the direct and joint effects of export regulations, credit markets and corruption in explaining exporting and OFDI from a country. Using country-level data from 96 developed and developing countries between 2000 and 2018, we test a series of hypotheses and examine nonlinearity in the relationships. The results of the study suggest that export regulations partially affect exporting but do not affect OFDI. Access to financial resources can be critical in parts for both exports and OFDI. The findings also show that corruption can have different implications for exports and OFDI. The interactions of corruption with export regulations and credit markets reveal some unexpected and counter-intuitive results, highlighting the importance of distinguishing between the direct and indirect (joint) effects of business environment factors and corruption on exports and OFDI. The results of the study contain important information for policymakers.
Implications of rising trade tensions for FDI projects
This paper offers preliminary evidence of the extent to which global FDI patterns have responded to the sharp increase in trade barriers since 2018, focusing in particular on the impact of new United States tariffs imposed on imports from China. Using detailed project-level data on new greenfield FDI as well as complementary research, this paper tracks the differential changes in FDI across countries and industries most affected by the trade tensions. There is some evidence of diversion to South-East Asia in specific industries, confirming findings of other research, but the aggregate effect on investment in China is limited and the overall effect on investment in South-East Asia is actually negative. A possible explanation lies in the importance of global value chain linkages as key determinants of firms’ investment decisions.
The relationship between perceived corruption and FDI: a longitudinal study in the context of Egypt
This paper investigates the dynamic relationship between perceived corruption and foreign direct investment (FDI) in Egypt during the period 1970–2019. Using a novel back-casting methodology, it extrapolates perceived corruption time series between 1970 and 1980. The results of the Johansen cointegration technique and the multivariate vector error correction model show a positive relationship between perceived corruption and FDI, supporting the “greasing the wheels” effect of corruption. This positive association can be explained by several factors, such as the cross-interdependence of rent-generating assets with perceived corruption and FDI, and the use of FDI data based on the balance of payments that has growing financial-flows and phantom-FDI components. The findings of this paper have important policy implications. Improving the fundamental governance structure in Egypt should be accompanied by a comprehensive investment facilitation strategy to compensate for the removal of “grease” from the “wheels”.
Globalization of innovation: the moderating role of project-level investment strategy and country type in location choice for R&D-related FDI
The current stage of globalization involves geographically dispersed research and development (R&D) investments that are not confined to advanced economies. These cross-border R&D investments are driven by multinational enterprises’ (MNEs’) strategies for exploring and/or exploiting foreign locations. In this paper, we analyse location choice and the moderating effect of project-level investment strategy (i.e. exploration or exploitation) and type of host economy (i.e. advanced or emerging) on the importance of the innovation framework and local innovation capabilities. Our analysis of 588 R&D-related foreign direct investment (FDI) projects in the pharmaceutical and biotech industries during the 2006–2016 period reveals that whereas a host country’s innovation framework and capability overall do affect the location decision, their ultimate effects are conditional on the combination of project-level investment strategy and type of economy. Our findings have policy implications for FDI policies aiming at enhancing linkages between MNEs and local actors and national science, technology, innovation and educational policies and programmes.
The global governance of FDI and the non-market strategies of TNCs: explaining the “backlash” against bilateral investment treaties
This article seeks to explain recent decisions by countries to terminate their existing bilateral investment treaties (BITs) and revisit their commitment to future international investment agreements (IIAs). It argues that BITs, transnational corporations (TNCs), host States and international arbitration institutions form a decentralized system of global governance of foreign direct investment (FDI), based on insights from the fields of international political economy and international law, and that the nonmarket strategies of these TNCs have not only shaped the contours of this system but have also prompted host States to reform this system, from the perspective of a “political bargaining model”. The article illustrates this argument through the case of South Africa, which terminated its BITs with several European countries as a response to cases of investor–State dispute settlement (ISDS) and has sought to redefine its engagement with this system of global governance as a result.
Post-pandemic reconfiguration from global to domestic and regional value chains: the role of industrial policies
The COVID-19 pandemic is expected to trigger a reconfiguration of global value chains according to four alternative trajectories: reshoring, regionalization, replication and diversification. This paper focuses on the first two scenarios. On the basis of a review of the extant reshoring literature and policies implemented in several major developed and emerging economies, we present a comprehensive framework to classify and analyse the evolution of such policies before and after the pandemic. The paper develops some policy recommendations suggesting that reshoring policies need to be supported by and combined with industrial policies enforcing the competitiveness and sustainability of production systems.
An evaluation of the effects of the European Commission’s proposals for the Common Consolidated Corporate Tax Base
This paper evaluates the Common Consolidated Corporate Tax Base (CCCTB) recently proposed by the European Commission. We find that if the CCCTB is introduced as it is currently proposed (including loss consolidation), then it is likely to impose large tax revenue costs of about one fifth of the corporate tax base. Second, we show that an application of the CCCTB proposals at only the European Union (EU) level would overlook the extent of profit shifting out of the EU and could lock in further unnecessary revenue losses. Third, major EU profit-shifting countries such as Luxembourg, Ireland and the Netherlands may experience significant revenue losses. Based on our analysis, the main policy recommendation is to consider extending the approach to a worldwide system, which would simultaneously deal with profit shifting within and out of the EU, and appears to offer the best prospect for revenue-positive, welfare-enhancing reform. For this to be viable, an immediate priority is to collate cross-country-comparable data and provide precise assessments of the range of policy scenarios.
Cultural spillovers from multinationalto domestic firms: Evidence on female employment in Costa Rica
We study cultural spillovers from multinational corporations (MNCs) to domestic companies in the information technology (IT) sector of Costa Rica. Using firm-level panel data for 2001–2011, we explore to what extent domestic firms’ female labour share increases as a result of business operations of MNCs. We find evidence of two channels for cultural spillovers from foreign direct investment (FDI) to domestic IT firms influencing higher shares of female employment: learning (imitation) effects through labour mobility, which allows former MNC employees working in domestic firms to apply skills and gender practices from their previous work experience, and demonstration effects with the presence of MNCs (through competition in the labour market), which include imitation of social norms and values of MNCs by local firms. No evidence was found for a relationship between backward linkages (purchases) of MNCs from domestic suppliers and female labour share. To promote greater participation by women in labour markets through FDI attraction, strengthening cultural spillovers would require implementing FDI promotion policies to (i) enhance the absorptive capacity of domestic IT firms, (ii) attract IT MNCs with greater potential to generate spillovers, and (iii) foster a favourable national investment climate for enhancing business interactions between IT MNCs and domestic IT firms.
Rapid FDI of emerging-market firms: foreign participation and leapfrogging in the establishment chain
This research explores the enablers of emerging-market firms (EMFs) leapfrogging in the internationalization process. Although many studies on rapid internationalization focus on exporting activities, we expand the concept to a higher-commitment entry mode: foreign direct investment (FDI). In addition, we investigate the role of an understudied force, foreign multinational enterprises (MNEs) in emerging markets, in enabling rapid internationalization of EMFs. Our hypotheses are tested using 1,612 first-time outward FDI projects from China between 2000 and 2014. The largely supported results suggest that minority foreign ownership and colocation with foreign MNEs allow EMFs to leapfrog certain stages in the establishment chain. Our findings offer alternative explanations, besides the government steward logic, to EMFs’ international expansion and contribute to the understanding, from a policy standpoint, that encouraging foreign-local partnerships is conducive to host-country industrial upgrading.
